I think Im swaying towards the strappy one it will be so good for avoiding tan lines, because you can easily switch the neckline. , But then the other one is such a great daytime dress you could By Anthropologie Long Sleeve Tie Front Mini Shirt Dress Anthropologie Cute White Dress Long Sleeve Skater Dress Tie Front Dress Lulus Six Stories Short Sleeved Chiffon Maxi Dress Vintage Cream Kloey Long Sleeve Knit Maxi Dress Cream Princess Polly If you struggle to find dresses that actually flatter your shape this is one of those that just works. The way this is designed pulls you in at the waist but still sits really nicely everywhere else.