Are you taking too much melatonin to help you sleep? The Case for Low Dose Melatonin Utzy Naturals Melatonin Side Effects: Is Melatonin Safe? Ro Solving your sleep woes with melatonin: From dosing instructions to timing supplementation, here's what you need to know about the natural sleep hormone. Thank you @gq for including me in this article on melatonin. Most people take it with the intention of using it as a sleeping pill, expecting a sedative effect. The answer is When Should You Take Melatonin for Sleep?